Basically, ice cream cake is the most amazing thing in baking existence. It marries two of my absolute favorite things: ice cream and fluffy cake. Unfortunately, it doesn’t last forever, though. Typically, ice cream cake lasts anywhere from a week to two months in the freezer.
Hello, there! My name is Michelle, and I have been a baker (and sugary sweets consumer) for over ten years. I enjoy every aspect of baking, from mixing ingredients to taste testing. Ice cream cake continues to rank highly on my list, so it is very important I know how to store it and how long it lasts.
If the party’s over and you’re wondering how long you can keep your delicious ice cream cake in the freezer, this article has your answer. Below, you will find everything you need to know about how long ice cream cake is good for in the freezer and how you can properly store it for the best shelf life (or should I say freezer life?).
Let’s talk about ice cream cakes!
- How Long Does Ice Cream Cake Last?
- How to Store Ice Cream Cake for Increased Longevity
- How Long Does Ice Cream Cake Last in the Fridge?
- Final Words
How Long Does Ice Cream Cake Last?
A lot of people think that ice cream cake will last for months on end. After all, it’s just a pairing of ice cream and cake, one of which is always kept in the freezer (the ice cream). That said, shouldn’t it be safe to eat even several months after the big party?
Not exactly. Ice cream cake can be stored for up to a week; the sooner, the better.
This isn’t necessarily because the cake goes bad. It’s not like if you take a bite out of a month-old ice cream cake, you’re going to get sick. The bigger issue is that ice crystals begin to form in the ice cream. This not only looks unappetizing but tastes disgusting, too.
Now, for ice cream cakes that do not have any kind of buttercream, whipped cream, egg, or cream cheese on the interior or exterior, the shelf life extends to two months. Of course, it’s still better to eat it as soon as possible.
How to Store Ice Cream Cake for Increased Longevity
Storing is going to make a world of difference when it comes to storing your ice cream cake. Always start with a high-quality freezer that can retain a low temperature. If you’re using an older freezer that has extensive temperature changes, your cake’s not going to last as long.
Regardless of the kind of freezer you own, do the following:
- Always seal and store the ice cream cake. If there is enough room, don’t settle for just sealing the ice cream cake with plastic wrap. You should also place it in an airtight container to avoid freezer burn. A freezer bag can be used too if you don’t have space.
- Store in the back of the freezer. The back of the freezer will be the chilliest location with the best chance of consistent temperatures. Here, your ice cream cake won’t meddle with too much, which will extend its lifespan.
Remember that even with the best-storing methods, ice cream cake is simply more prone to freezer burn than other kinds of baked goods, even a “regular” cake without ice cream. So, while your vanilla cake from last year may have lasted months, this will not be true for this cake.
How Long Does Ice Cream Cake Last in the Fridge?
Since ice cream cakes contain a frozen treat – ice cream – they cannot be stored in the fridge. Placing an ice cream cake in the fridge may be ideal a few hours before the party begins, but it should not be stored there for an extended period.
After only a few short hours in the fridge, an ice cream cake will begin the melting process. So, if it’s left in the fridge for 24 hours or more, you’re going to find yourself with quite a mess. Don’t try it – stick it to the freezer.
Ice cream cake doesn’t last as long as you might think. It should be consumed as soon as possible. If you’re still curious about how long ice cream cake lasts, then check out these questions below.
How long do Dairy Queen ice cream cakes last?
Dairy Queen ice cream cakes aren’t really different from any other ice cream cakes on the market. The cakes are still prone to the 7-day freezer rule as ice crystals can begin to form in these cakes, too.
How do you keep ice cream cake fresh?
The best way to keep ice cream cake fresh is to make sure that it is sealed properly. As mentioned in a previous section, ice cream cakes should be wrapped in plastic wrap and placed in a freezer bag or airtight container.
How long can an ice cream cake sit out?
Ice cream cakes should not sit out long. That is why I recommend you start cutting ice cream cake ten minutes after you take it out of the freezer. Ice cream cake will melt quickly, starting at the ten-minute mark.
When should I take my ice cream cake out of the freezer?
You can place your ice cream cake in the fridge about an hour before the event to make sure that it’s softened enough to take out, cut, and serve. On the other hand, you can go directly from the freezer to the countertop, leaving about ten minutes for the cake to soften up.
Can ice cream cake spoil?
If an ice cream cake is left sitting out, it will spoil and make you sick if consumed. However, ice cream cake will not spoil in the freezer for several months. Again, the issue is ice crystals forming rather than “spoilage” (although it will taste rancid).
If you love ice cream cake like me, you need to know how long it lasts – and now you are an expert. Ice cream cake lasts for around a week in the fridge and should be consumed as soon as possible. Certain cakes and situations can extend the lifespan to two months.
How long did you think that ice cream cakes last in the freezer?About Michelle