Brownies are one of the best things to bake, whether you’re baking a batch for your family or planning to sell them locally. But trying to slice perfectly-shaped brownies of the same size can be tricky.
Thankfully, you can put these worries to rest with a brownie pan with dividers. My favorite is the Wilton Brownie Bar Pan, and I’m sure you’ll love it, too.
Hey, there! My name is Michelle, and I love baking brownies! I love regular chocolate brownies, but I have also dipped into other unique flavors like dark chocolate espresso and raspberry delights. There are so many possibilities, but they’re all delectable.
I have made plenty of brownies without special dividers, and sure, that works just fine. But you don’t get the precise, picture-perfect square without them. After I started using brownie pans with dividers, I never went back.
My go-to brownie pan with a divider is the Wilton pan. It’s constructed of non-stick stainless steel so that you can remove your single-serving treats without hassle. It’s also super simple to clean, which is essential when you do as much baking as I do.
I know everyone has their own needs for baking products, though. Some people might want bigger or smaller brownies, while others prefer a material other than steel. That’s why I have created this comprehensive list of the five best brownie pans with dividers.
What are we waiting for? I can’t wait to share!
- Best Brownie Pan with Divider: Top Picks
- Best Brownie Pan with Divider: Things to Consider
Best Brownie Pan with Divider: Top Picks
To come up with my must-see list, I researched brownie pans and paid close attention to their features and reviews. Let’s get started.
1. Wilton Brownie Bar Pan (Top Choice)
- Key Features: Non-stick, wide edges for gripping, budget-friendly, dishwasher-safe, even heat distribution
- Number of Brownies: 12
- Material: Stainless Steel
- Size: 1.56 x 10.81 x 15.85 inches
My main focus is reliability and ease of use when it comes to baking products. And that’s why I love this brownie pan with a divider from Wilton. It comes with 12 slots for brownies, which means there’s plenty for the whole family and me to enjoy.
The most prominent feature of this brownie pan is the non-stick stainless steel construction. Steel is durable and provides even heat distribution, essential for perfect brownies every time. Being non-stick, you can easily slide out your treats when they’re done baking. So easy!
This pan is also easy to clean. It is 100% dishwasher-safe, which means less time scrubbing in the kitchen sink and more time enjoying your freshly baked brownies. Did I mention it’s a very budget-friendly option, too? If you’re looking for a top-notch pan on a budget, this is it.
One thing to keep in mind is that the cavities are relatively large and deep, which means you’ll get some pretty generous-sized brownie portions. This was a surprise for some. For me? It was a match made in heaven.
2. Brooklyn Brownie Copper by Gotham Steel Nonstick Baking Pan (Best Aluminum Option)
- Key Features: Non-stick, detachable divider, dishwasher-safe, even heat distribution, won’t warp, corrode, or stain
- Number of Brownies: 18
- Material: Aluminum
- Size: 14.09 x 9.19 x 2.59 inches
Many people have heard of Gotham Steel, especially when it comes to late-night infomercials. Well, they’re more than just a grabby commercial. Gotham Steel cookware really is a top-notch product, and that’s why I included this brownie pan with a divider.
This pan is designed using food-grade, non-toxic heavy-weight aluminized steel. It won’t warp, corrode, or stain, and the non-stick coating ensures brownies are released in a flash. Thanks to the premium materials, this pan is also 100% dishwasher-safe for your convenience.
A significant benefit of this brownie pan with divider is that it comes with an impressive 18 cavities for brownies. This allows for slightly smaller brownies to share with the neighborhood. (There is also an XL option to make 24 brownies!)
Some customers have struggled with slight seepage while baking brownies. You can avoid any messy mishaps by placing a baking sheet underneath. Keep in mind that this problem didn’t affect everyone, and you might consider replacing it if you struggle with seepage.
3. Silivo Silicone Brownie Pan (Best Silicone Pick)
- Key Features: Food-grade silicone, non-stick, flexible, dishwasher-safe
- Number of Brownies: 12 or 24
- Material: Silicone
- Size: 13 x 8 x 0.6 inches
Many people desire silicone baking pans because they are known for their non-stick properties. They’re also entirely flexible, so you can “pop out” your treats. This simply isn’t possible with other types of baking equipment.
If you stan silicone, you will love the Silivo Silicone Brownie Pan. This flexible, non-stick silicone pan is made of 100% food-grade silicone and is an eco-friendly option for those concerned about the planet.
There are two available size options: 12 and 24. Regardless of the size you choose, you can expect easy cleanup in the dishwasher. Just make sure that you’re only using this pan in temperatures from -20F to 450F to avoid damage.
This brownie pan with dividers is shallower than most other pans on this list, which should be considered before buying. This isn’t necessarily a bad thing if you’re looking to bake thinner brownies.
4. Ailelan Brownie Pan (2-in-1 Pan)
- Key Features: Non-stick, won’t rust or stain, dishwasher-safe, removable divider, versatile
- Number of Brownies: 18
- Material: High Carbon Steel
- Size: 12 x 8 x 2 inches
Sometimes you want uniform brownies, and sometimes you want it to be a free for all. If you’re someone that wants a bigger bang for their buck and more versatility from their product, then you’ll enjoy the Ailelan Brownie Pan.
What’s to love? Well, the most significant feature of this pan is that the metal divider is entirely detachable. So, whether you’re making brownies or roasting vegetables, you can use the same pan.
The pan is designed with food-grade high carbon steel, allowing faster heat transfer and even distribution for brownies that come out perfect. With 18 pre-sliced non-stick sections, you can feed a crowd effortlessly.
While the removable divider is convenient, it is slightly on the flimsy side. Be extra careful when removing and inserting it to avoid any potential damage. Take care when washing the edges, too.
5. Baker’s Edge Brownie Pan (Best S-Shaped Pan)
- Key Features: S-shaped chamber, allows easier batter spreading, multiple chewy edges, easy to clean
- Number of Brownies: Single Chamber – Your Call
- Material: Carbon Steel
- Size: 13 x 9 x 2 inches
Do you want a little more freedom when it comes to how big or small your brownies are? Then you will love the Baker’s Edge Brownie Pan, specifically designed with a single S-shaped chamber so you can be in charge of brownie slice sizes.
This pan is the epitome of “freedom” for brownies, but it still offers multiple chewy edges for those who love the end pieces. Designed with heavy-duty aluminum and coated with a silicone-based non-stick material, this food-grade pan is hefty and non-stick.
The S-shaped chamber is not only built for freedom of cutting, though. It also allows for easier spreading of brownie batter, which can be a challenge with pre-cut slices. At the end of your baking adventure, easily clean this S-shaped wonder in your dishwasher.
Since this pan is made with heavy-duty carbon steel, it’s heavier than the other brownie pans on this list. It’s also on the pricier side. Many shoppers said it was worth the price, though. So if you don’t mind spending more on gorgeous brownies, this is the pan for you.
Best Brownie Pan with Divider: Things to Consider
I know you’re excited to start making picture-perfect, Instagram-worthy brownies. But there are a few key details you need to consider before buying.
For me, I prefer to have extra-large and thick indulgent brownies. Others prefer a smaller, thinner brownie that won’t budge them off their diet. Which one are you? Consider how many brownies the pan makes and how thick they will be.
I’m a fan of the classic stainless steel, but that doesn’t mean everyone is. You can join me and purchase a steel option or breakout from the mold and opt for silicone, aluminum, or another crowd favorite.
Detachable or Undetachable Divider
Some of these brownie pans come with removable dividers, which is excellent if you want to use your brownie pan in more than one way (or just conveniently slide the divider into your brownie batter). Others might prefer pre-cut slices. Choose the pan that reflects your wants and needs.
The final thing to consider is the weight of the pan. Some people really don’t want to struggle with heavy pans, and that’s understandable. Check out the weight of each pan if that is something you’re concerned about.
There are many excellent brownie pans with divider options on this list. My favorite is the Wilton Brownie Bar Pan, though, because it’s a simple yet reliable pan that produces thick and ooey-gooey brownie slices time and time again.About Michelle