5 Best Silicone Baking Cups

Silicone baking cups are one of the best materials to bake with. They’re super simple to use and even easier to clean. The primary benefit is that baked treats can fall or “pop” right out of the silicone baking cup, putting the days of nightmare stickiness to rest.

My favorite is the Amazon Basics Reusable Silicone Baking Cups.

Hey, there! I’m Michelle, and I’ve spent the last ten years perfecting my baking skill and becoming a rockstar in the kitchen. While I will admit I have plenty of bakeware with different materials filling my kitchen cabinets, one of my favorites is silicone.

Trust me – if you haven’t tried baking with silicone yet, you’re missing out. Whether you’re baking delectable muffins or birthday cupcakes, silicone is going to make your job 100% easier. But with so many on the market, it can be tricky to pinpoint which one is “best.”

Well, bakers, if you’re new to the world of silicone muffin cups, I recommend the 12 or 24-pack of reusable silicone baking cups from Amazon Basics. They allow baked treats to slide right out, and cleanup is a breeze. I also love that they repel stains and odors, which isn’t true for all options.

If you’re ready to dive into the incredible world of silicone baking, follow me. In this article, you will discover the top five silicone baking cups on the market. Whether you’re a fan of little round cups or need something rectangular, you will find it – and so much more – below. 

Let’s get baking!

Best Silicone Baking Cups: Top Picks

I know what you’re thinking – “Why are these the best?” Plenty of research went into finding the top five. In the end, I based my decision on which cups ultimately had the greatest features, price tag, and positive reviews. What are we waiting for?

1. Amazon Basics Reusable Silicone Baking Cup (Number One Pick)

• Key Features: Colorful, safe up to 428F, dishwasher-safe, BPA-free silicone, nonstick, easy food release, stain resistant, odor resistant
• Dimensions: 2.9 x 2.96 x 1.3 inches
• # Per Package: 12 or 24 cups

Technically, I don’t shop “AmazonBasics” far too often. But they really knocked this one out of the ballpark. The Amazon Basics reusable silicone baking cups are by far the best option. Here’s why.

For one, I love that you can buy 12 or 24-count packages. As someone who bakes very regularly, I like having 24 to pick and choose from. While one is washing (in the dishwasher, I might add), the other set is working hard in the oven (safe up to 428F).

These silicone baking cups are notably some of the easiest cups to work with, too. The BPA-free silicone is shockingly stick-free for effortless food release every time. They also prevent stains and odors, making them easily reusable without any nuisances.

Cleaning is a bit finicky. For one, treats must be cooled entirely before trying to remove them. If washing by hand, flip it inside out for the best results. When cleaned in the dishwasher, they must be positioned correctly not to flip over. Otherwise, they’ll remain dirty.

2. Ielek Silicone Cupcake Muffin Baking Cups (Most Versatile)

• Key Features: Three shapes included, big bang for your buck, versatile, easy food release, BPA and PVC-free, dishwasher-safe, safe up to 446F
• Dimensions: Square (2.76×2.76×1.26), rectangle (3.15×1.97×1.18), round (2.75×1.25)
• # Per Package: 36 pieces 

Sure, having some handy silicone baking cups for your muffin tin is great. But what if you need other shapes? Plenty of recipes requires square and/or rectangles to achieve success. And when those moments call, you can answer with this three-pack from Ielek.

This is undeniably the most versatile option on this list. Inside each package, you will have square, rectangular, and round silicone baking cups to tackle all of your baking challenges. Each one comes with a vibrant shade such as yellow or pink to really make your treats “pop.”

These BPA and PVC-free silicone baking cups won’t disappoint for easy release. They’re safe in temperatures ranging from -104F to 446F, and when you’re ready, all your goodies slide right out of the cup – regardless of the shape you’re utilizing.

Some buyers said these cups were slightly thinner than they thought, shocking after opening the packaging. Again, the best thing to do is double-check the dimensions before buying anything such as silicone baking cups.

3. Honbay Silicone Rectangular Reusable Cake Cup Sets (Best Rectangular Silicone Cups)

• Key Features: Rectangle shape for cakes and bread loaves, dishwasher-safe, safe up to 450F, easy food release, ultra-flexible and soft
• Dimensions: 3.27×1.81×0.79 inches
• # Per Package: 12

Most baked treats are a-okay with a round silicone baking cup. Others aren’t. That’s why I added the Honbay rectangular baking cups to my top five list. I mean, after all, how are you going to make your notorious chocolate chip banana bread without one of these?

These rectangular silicone baking cups are a great addition to any kitchen. They’re great on their own but even better when paired with round silicone baking cups. Variety is the spice of life, and you’ll love having this option when you want to make miniature loaves of bread, cake, and more.

Ultra-flexible and soft, these light and bright rectangular silicone cups allow easy release of all of your treats. They’re safe up to 450F, making them one of the tougher options on this list. With 12 pieces per pack, the world is your oyster – or should we say cake?

In the previous paragraph, I mentioned that these silicone baking cups were soft and flexible. And I was not lying. These are intensely flexible and flimsy, so you will need to be extra careful when maneuvering them – especially when they’re filled with batter.

4. GREENRAIN Reusable Silicone Baking Cups (Most Shapes)

• Key Features: Six shapes, four lovely colors, BPA and PVC-free, no Phthalates, easy food release, versatile
• Dimensions: 2.6 x 1.2 inches
• # Per Package: 24

When you’re making muffins, cupcakes, or another round treat, sticking with the typical circular shape can get kind of humdrum. If you want to add some pizzazz to your baking, you’re going to enjoy this whimsical pack of silicone baking cups from Green Rain.

This pack comes with six shapes: round, star, heart, rose, butterfly, and petal. Each shape is adorned with lovely colors, including pink, purple, green, and blue. With so many colors and shape options, you can really bring out your creativity with ease and “wow” your friends and family members.

These silicone baking cups aren’t just great to look at; they’re a healthy choice, too. They are free of any BPA, PVC, or Phthalate and don’t have any undesired white fillers when twisted. They can handle up to 446F and are entirely reusable and eco-friendly. Yes, please!

These were also on the thinner and flimsier side than desired, but that did not compromise the efficiency. Shoppers said they worked like a charm – you just have to get used to handling them properly.

5. To encounter 41 Pieces Silicone Bakeware Set(Best Baking Set)

• Key Features: Set with five pans and 36 baking cups, cups come in three shapes and four colors, BPA-free, safe up to 446F, extremely versatile, handy gripping handles 
• Dimensions: 11.42 x 9.09 x 5.08 inches (altogether)
• # Per Package: 41

I know you came here for the best silicone baking cups, but I couldn’t resist adding this versatile silicone baking set to the list. This is reserved for those who have turned into absolute silicone fanatics and want it to extend into every area of their baking life.

I love this set because it comes with all the accessories you will ever need, including a baking sheet, muffin pan, loaf pan, donut pan, cake pan, and 36 baking cups. Together, this is the ultimate “silicone baking cup” set on the market.

Aside from its versatility (and friendly price tag, I might add), this baking set is highly convenient. They come with just the right amount of durability and flexibility to give you confidence from beginning to end. The gripping handles are a massive plus for maneuvering, too.

The pans are a bit on the small side, but they still get the job done flawlessly. Honestly, you will love having these nonstick pans and baking cups in your kitchen arsenal to tackle all of your baking needs.

Best Silicone Baking Cups: Things to Consider

Silicone baking cups are going to change the way you bake for good, regardless of which pack you end up with. However, you should consider a few things before deciding which one to buy. Let’s check it out.

Size

Not all baking cups are created equal. Some will have more width and depth than others. It’s essential to check the dimensions before buying so you’re not surprised with a too-big or too-little baking cup.

Shape

I highly recommend buying some round silicone baking cups to have on hand. But why stop there? Rectangles are essential for specific recipes like cakes and bread. On the other hand, playful shapes like stars and hearts are easy to add some fun to your baking routine.

Number of Pieces

Newbie bakers might not need a whole mess of silicone baking cups, so finding a simple pack with 12 should be fine. For those that do a lot of baking (with no end in sight), you’re going to want to find a larger pack to accommodate your needs.

Verdict

You’re going to be a fan of silicone baking cups – I just know it! To get you started, I highly recommend the  Amazon Basics Reusable Silicone Baking Cup. These are great baking cups that won’t disappoint. 

Do you like to use silicone bakeware? Which one do you use? Feel free to share your ideas below.

I have been a lover of sweets since day one. This led me on a self-taught baking journey starting at the age of 13. It's been over 10 years since the start of my baking adventures, and I’ve learned a lot along the way. Now, people rave about my delectable treats, whether it’s a chocolate cake or a strawberry crepe.