Most people have baking sheets in their homes but don’t pay attention to those with wire racks. Well, a baking sheet with a wire rack opens a realm of baking and cooking potential you won’t want to ignore. To help you on these cooking adventures, the Nordic Ware Oven Crisp Baking Tray is a great choice.
My name is Michelle, and I spend more time in my kitchen than the average person. I am always looking to try out new and exciting recipes or stick to a few of my top faves. Whether it’s a new or tried-and-true recipe, my baking sheet with a wire rack always comes in handy.
I chose the Nordic Ware baking tray because it’s a hassle-free way to make all kinds of creations, from perfectly crispy bacon to amazing roasted veggies. The edges are thick and easily graspable, with pouring spouts for easy cleanup.
What works for me might not work for everyone, though. While the Nordic Ware checks all my must-have boxes, others might be looking for something a bit different. That’s why this review has two other great baking trays with wire racks you won’t want to miss.
Let’s find out which baking sheets with wire racks ranked in the top three!
Best Baking Sheet with Wire Rack: Top Choices
Below you will find an in-depth look at the top three baking sheets with wire racks on the market with a comprehensive overview of their pros and cons. Let’s dive in.
1. Nordic Ware Oven Crisp Baking Tray (Best Overall)
- Key features: Easy clean, impressive depth, pouring spouts, nonstick rack
- Size: 17.1 x 12.4 x 1.4 inches
- Material: Aluminum
- Weight: 1.91 pounds
- Dishwasher safe: No
The thing I like best about the Nordic Ware Oven Crisp Baking Tray is that there is an impressive depth of 1.40 inches. This is important when you’re cooking up something greasy, such as bacon, and you need a safe place for the drippings to land.
Another enjoyable feature is the pouring spouts. Again, this all comes down to ease of cleanup. When you’re dealing with super hot drippings, the last thing you want to do is fiddle with it. With the pouring spouts, eliminating the drippings safely and effectively is a breeze.
Last but not least, I like the thick edges of the baking sheet. I have struggled with baking sheets that were challenging to pick up in the past. With wider and thicker edges, you can pick up the hot baking sheet and wire rack with ease – no more burnt fingers or slipping!
Unfortunately, this pan is a little difficult to clean. While the cooking rack is nonstick, the actual baking sheet is not. If you don’t amply wash it (by hand) after cooking, it will develop spots that can’t be removed.
2. The French Pantry Cookie Sheet Pan Set (Best Value)
- Key features: Three pack with silicone mat, budget-friendly, rust-resistant
- Size: 18.11 x 12.99 x 1.97 inches
- Material: Aluminum, Stainless, Silicone
- Weight: 1 Pound
- Dishwasher safe: Yes
The French Pantry Cookie Sheet Pan Set comes with everything you need for the perfect baking adventure: an aluminum half sheet pan, a silicone mat, and one stainless steel cooling rack. With these three must-haves, nothing in the kitchen is off-limits.
Aside from being a convenient trio, another big plus is that the half sheet pan and cooling rock are entirely rust-resistant. This means you won’t have to worry about replacing your product anytime soon, leaving way more time for whipping up your favorite recipes.
Now, don’t think that just because this set comes with three handy pieces that it costs an arm and a leg. This trio is surprisingly budget-friendly, making it a great value you won’t want to miss out on.
One of the benefits of this set is that it comes with a silicone mat. This makes it easy to bake all kinds of goods, sweet and savory. It’s also the slight downfall to this pack, though. The mat retains oil and can be challenging to clean.
3. CasaWare 3pc Ultimate Cookie Sheet/Cooling Grid Set (Best Carbon Steel Option)
- Key features: Carbon steel pan, rose gold cooling grid, Scratch-resistant
- Size: 16.5 x 11.3 x 1.77 inches
- Material: Carbon Steel
- Weight: 5.05 Pound
- Dishwasher safe: No
Plenty of people are fans of carbon steel cookware. Sound like you? Then you’ll appreciate that the CasaWare Set comes with a carbon steel pan that’s 100% scratch-resistant and nonstick.
While the carbon steel pan is something to rave about, it’s not the only thing setting this set apart from the competition. The cooling grid is made of an impressive rose gold material, complete with handles for easy gripping and five feet on the bottom to avoid direct contact with your kitchen countertops.
If you’re worried about buying a baking sheet with a wire rack that has harmful ingredients, you don’t have to worry with this product. The carbon steel pan is free of PTFE, cadmium, lead, PFOA, and PFOS, making it a top-notch and safe pan to cook with.
The only slight drawback to this baking sheet is it’s smaller than the other options on this list. While that might not be a big deal for some – especially those with smaller ovens or families – others might find it too small to handle their cooking tasks.
Best Baking Sheet with Wire Rack: What to Consider
There are a few things to consider before buying a baking sheet with a wire rack.
One of the biggest things to consider is the material – of the baking sheet and the wire rack. Some are stronger than others and come with their realm of benefits. For example, aluminum is reliable and sturdy, but carbon steel is nonstick and scratch-resistant.
What are you planning to cook or cake? This can determine what size pan you need. Also, consider the size of your oven. Some are smaller than others, and will need to be assessed before buying.
A baking sheet isn’t more than that. It’s designed to hold your ingredients while it bakes. But some baking sheets with wire racks are different. For example, my top pick comes with handy pouring spouts that make cleanup an absolute breeze.
There are many excellent baking sheets with wire racks on the market, but these three are the best options. One might be more suitable for you than another, but the Nordic Ware Oven Crisp Baking Tray is a versatile and reliable choice you won’t regret.About Michelle