Best 9×13 Cake Pans (Top 8 Choices)

A few key things are needed for baking a cake, such as sugar, flour, and oh, of course! A cake pan. 

If you’re trying to bake a cake without a reliable cake pan, chances are you’re not getting your desired results. Use a high-quality pan like the USA Pan Bakeware Rectangular Cake Pan, and you won’t be sorry.

Hey, everyone! My name is Michelle and cakes are life. As I always say, “Let them eat cake.” Okay, so Marie-Antoinette said that, but I am in complete agreement. There is just something about a cake that makes any event extraordinary. 

A 9×13 cake pan is one of those must-have staples every kitchen needs, especially if you like to bake cakes. Why? Aside from round cakes, 9×13 cakes are the most popular size. If you try to use another sized pan, it can be challenging to get identical results. 

Consider the USA pan if you’re in the market for a 9×13 baking pan. These are pans manufactured in the USA, and each comes with the notorious Americoat non-stick coating. They’re made with a fluted design for easy food release and effortless cleanup, too. 

I’m sure anyone would love the USA pan, but I understand everyone has their wants and needs. For that reason, I have found the top eight 9×13 pans on the market. Below, you will find precisely what you’re looking for, whether you’re a fan of ceramic or prefer silicone material.

Let’s get baking!

Best 9×13 Cake Pan: Top Picks

If you search for the “best 9×13 cake pan”, you’re going to be inundated with hundreds of options. Talk about overwhelming. Well, I made the job easy for you. I sifted through all of those cake pans to find the top eight on the market. Browse and find the one you like!

1. USA Pan Bakeware Rectangular Cake Pan, 9 x 13 inch (Top Choice)

• Key Features:
• Material: Alloy Steel
• Depth: 2.25 inches
• Weight: 1.96 pounds

My oh my, do I love these pans. Honestly, there are a seemingly endless amount of features with these made-in-the-USA pans. Where do I start? How about the fact that each pan comes with Americoat, a state-of-the-art and toxin-free coating that allows for effortless cake release and cleanup?

Not sold yet? Well, what if I told you these pans come complete with a fluted design on the base? The textured surface allows for two things. For one, it allows for proper air circulation, so cakes are baked evenly and exquisitely every time.

Secondly, the unique grooves ensure that no residue can get stuck on the pan. With a quick swipe of a sponge, the rib-like texture will release any stuck-on mess or grime, ensuring you have a swift and effortless cleanup: no more hassles, no more frustrations.

Clearly, the USA cake pan is the superior choice that should wind up in your kitchen. However, keep in mind that they’re a bit heavier than some other cake pans on the market. The packaging can also be sub-par. If it arrives damaged, just ask the seller to replace it, and they will. No worries!

2. GreenLife Bakeware Healthy Ceramic Cake Pan, 13″ x 9″ (Best Ceramic Pick)

• Key Features: Reinforced rims, steel base, safe up to 450F, healthy and toxin-free, ceramic coating, non-stick, easy to clean
• Material: Aluminum
• Depth: 1.97 inches
• Weight: 1.47 pounds

Serious ceramic fans will want to walk – no, run – to buy this cake pan from GreenLife. Not only is this a brand that focuses on safety and health, but their products are effortless and straightforward, the ideal choice for any baker.

Why this pan? Let’s start with the ceramic coating (derived from sand) that allows cakes to literally glide out of the pan. The coating is entirely free of toxins, such as PFA, PFOA, or lead, making it a safe way to bake the healthiest (and unhealthiest) cakes.

Underneath the must-have ceramic coating, you will find a heavy-duty steel base. Not only does this provide the stability every baker dreams of when making crave-worthy cakes, but it allows for even heat distribution. The reinforced rims are just an added touch!

This pan is hand wash only, which is already a big sigh. But to add insult to injury, it’s also highly susceptible to scratches. Luckily, the ceramic coating is a cinch to clean, so you shouldn’t have to scrub too hard or use abrasive materials to get it to look brand new.

3. Lindy’s Stainless Steel 9 X 13 Inches Covered Cake Pan (Best Cake Pan With Lid)

• Key Features: Ultra-durable and strong, comes with a snap-on cover, plenty of depth, added security on the bottom
• Material: Stainless Steel
• Depth: 2.5 inches
• Weight: 3.9 pounds

Are you tired of flimsy cake pans that don’t get the job done? Do you want a cake pan with a solid cover rather than a typical rickety lid? Then you’re going to fall in love with this stainless steel cake pan from Lindy’s.

This cake pan is built to last. Constructed using heavy 18/10 stainless steel, you don’t have to worry about this pan breaking down – even when it comes to face to face with the most substantial and heaviest cakes you can create.

The pan isn’t the only robust item in this set, though. The snap-on lid is designed with stainless steel, too, so it can be just as strong and reliable. Needless to say, this is a top-notch cake pan and cover set whether you’re planning to travel with your cakes or not.

The biggest potential drawback to this set is that the cover is slightly challenging to remove. You’re going to have to use your muscles and strain a bit to get that thing off. This isn’t a big negative, though. It just means that the lid is secure, which provides confidence to the baker.

4. Milcraft Silicone Rectangular Cake Pans (Best Silicone Option)

• Key Features:
• Material: Silicone
• Depth: 1.57 inches
• Weight: 0.22 pounds

Do you stan silicone? Then, of course, you need to dive into the fantastic world of silicone cake pans, and this pan from Milcraft is a great place to start. It’s designed with the highest-grade European silicone out there, ensuring the perfect combination of strength and durability.

Aside from holding its original shape, another big “plus” is the non-stick coating. This essential coating paired with utmost flexibility ensures that all of your cakes can be popped out of the pan once cooled. It doesn’t get any easier than that!

And don’t worry. Unlike other silicone baking products, this BPA-free silicone cake pan has enough durability to stand on its own. You don’t have to worry about putting a baking sheet underneath. Simply add your batter, place it in the oven (up to 500F), and get cookin’. 

The only area that this cake pan slightly lacks is depth. It doesn’t have as much depth as typical cake pans, which means you won’t get as high of a cake. It isn’t a huge difference, but enough for people to notice a slight change to their final result.

5. Wilton Recipe Right Non-Stick 9 x 13-Inch Oblong Cake Pans (Best Value)

• Key Features: Set of two, budget-friendly, non-stick, scratch-resistant, durable material, dishwasher-safe
• Material: Alloy Steel
• Depth: 2 inches
• Weight: 1.43 pounds

Are you looking for great value? I have you covered, baker! This set of two cake pans from Wilton is precisely what you need to stock up on essential 9×13 non-stick cake pans without emptying your entire bank account to do so.

You will love these cake pans because they’re designed with sturdy steel construction that ensures long-lasting use without warping. Covered in a non-stick and scratch-resistant coating, you don’t have to worry about stuck-on messes and grime or being too rough with your sponge.

Although this set of two is surprisingly cheap, it doesn’t slack on quality. You will get a pair of pans that get the job done effortlessly. Slide the cakes out when finished baking and place the pan in the dishwasher. (Then use the other pan for baking another cake, of course.)

After prolonged use, you might find that these pans start to rust and stain. You can attempt to avoid this by washing by hand as much as possible. The good news is these pans are so cost-effective that it won’t hurt to buy another set a few years down the line!

6. Stock Your Home Foil Pans with Lids (Best Disposable 9×13 Cake Pans)

• Key Features: Eco-friendly, recyclable, reusable, dishwasher-safe, comes with pack of 25 or 30, comes with accompanying lid, durable and reliable
• Material: Aluminum Foil
• Depth: 2.5 inches
• Weight: 1 pound

If you plan to make a lot of cakes to-go this year, I would highly recommend buying some disposable cake pans. Otherwise, you’re going to end up with lost pans along the way – and that’s a big waste of money, not to mention a hassle when you’re ready to bake again!

Consider this pack from Stock Your Home for all of your disposable cake pan needs. This value pack comes with 25, or 30 disposable cake pans complete with lids. Each pan is constructed using heavy-duty aluminum foil, creating a hefty surface that is 100% recyclable.

Of course, you don’t have to recycle right after use. These disposable cake pans are entirely reusable. Just slip them into the dishwasher, let the washer run a complete cycle, and your pan and lid are ready for the next birthday party. So simple!

While these reusable cake pans are relatively strong, they’re thinner than other reusable options. It doesn’t affect overall quality or efficiency. However, you need to be careful when transporting heavy items (big cakes). It can bend in the middle, so support from the bottom is ideal.

7. Rachael Ray Yum-O Nonstick Bakeware Cake Pan, 9″ x 13″ (Best Handles)

• Key Features: Superior gripping handles, multiple handle color options, durable and reliable, non-stick, safe up to 500F
• Material: Alloy Steel
• Depth: 2.2 inches
• Weight: 1.5 pounds

This cake pan got the “best handle” award? Is that really something to cheer for? Well, thank you for asking. Yes, yes, it is. Have you ever tried to maneuver a cake pan with sub-par or non-existent handles? Uh, it’s a challenge and can seriously ruin your day (hello, spilled batter).

The Rachael Ray cake pan is a must-have for anyone serious about their handles and avoiding mishaps in the kitchen. The colorful handles allow superior gripping for an overall confident grasp regardless of the cake you’re making.

Aside from the superior handles, this pan is constructed using heavy-gauge steel to fend off warping. It is safe up to 500F, which means almost no cake recipe is off-limits. Oh, and don’t worry – it comes covered in a non-stick coating for hassle-free cake removal you can count on.

This cake pan is a bit susceptible to scratching. You need to be extra careful when cleaning these pans to avoid this. Use a soft sponge or washcloth rather than an abrasive product.

8. Wilton Recipe Right Non-Stick 9 x 13-Inch Pan (Budget Pick)

• Key Features: Budget-friendly, includes a lid, durable, dishwasher-safe, non-stick
• Material: Alloy Steel
• Depth: 2 inches
• Weight: 1.5 pounds

In this day and age, most people are looking for a bargain. I get it – cake pans aren’t exactly in the dollar bin, and the ingredients to make a cake have skyrocketed. But don’t worry. If you’re on a tight budget, this Wilton cake pan is here to save the day.

Wilton has consistently made reliable products for years, and the best part is they’re always cost-effective. This cake pan is no different. It’s designed with steel for durability plus a non-stick coating you can depend on. Cakes slide right out, and clean-up is an absolute breeze.

This cake pan also comes with a convenient lid, making it the perfect (cheap) set whether you’re leaving it on your kitchen countertop or taking it over to your niece’s birthday party. It’s dishwasher-safe for your convenience, although I would recommend hand washing most of the time.

Although the lid is handy, it can be tricky to get it to snap on. Think of it this way – the cover fits like a glove. You’re going to need a little elbow grease to get it to connect to the cake pan. Honestly, that’s not really a bad thing. At least you know it won’t pop off!

Best 9×13 Cake Pan: Things to Consider

Need a little help choosing which 9×13 cake pan to buy? Then keep reading. Below are the top five things to consider when searching for 9×13 cake pans.

Depth

We already know the size of the cake pans, so we don’t need to worry about that. But the one dimension we do need to look at its depth. Not all 9×13 pans have the same depth. If you want higher cakes, you will need a cake pan that’s deep enough to accommodate them.

Material

Silicone? Stainless steel? Aluminum? There are many different choices, and each comes with its slew of pros and cons. Find which material is best for you and your needs.

Weight

Ok, so none of these pans will be 100 pounds (thank goodness!). But some will be heftier than others. Some people really don’t like their pans to be heavy, as this can pose a challenge when filled with batter. Make sure to check out the “weight” section!

Added Features

All of these pans are unique in the way they are designed, so it is crucial to look at the features listed below the product name. For example, the Rachael Ray has the best handles, while the Lindy’s has a robust accompanying cover.

Price

Last but not least, don’t forget pricing! I have a wide range of products on this list. Some cake pans are over $30, while others are under $10. Pay attention to your budget and stick to it. (Don’t break the bank for a premium cake pan!)

Final Verdict

While I would definitely use any of these cake pans in my kitchen, I believe the USA Pan Bakeware Rectangular Cake Pan, 9 x 13 inch is the best option. It’s suitable for everyone with a fluted design and non-stick surface you can rely on. It’s not too expensive, either, which is a big plus.

Do you have a 9×13 cake pan? How do you like it? Feel free to share your experience with us!

About Michelle