If you’re not baking muffins using a silicone pan, are you even baking? Okay, I might be exaggerating – but only a little. Silicone pans make it a breeze to bake and offer quick clean-up, and the CakeTime Silicone Muffin Pan is the best choice.
Hi, there! My name is Michelle, and I love muffins. There is something so delightful yet straightforward about muffins, whether you’re baking a savory breakfast egg muffin or rocketing your taste buds to new heights with double chocolate fudge.
Through my baking journey, I have used so many different pans. I stumbled upon silicone a few years back and couldn’t be happier. Silicone makes it so easy to bake without stuck-on muffin messes. They’re safe and effective in all temperatures with easy clean-up, too.
I like the CakeTime Silicone Muffin Pan when it comes to baking muffins. It makes 12 muffins (enough for my family and me) and is entirely flexible and non-stick, allowing easy muffin pop-outs. It can handle temperatures from -104F to 446F, making it a versatile pick.
I’ll level with you, though. This pan might not be suitable for every shopper. Some might want jumbo or miniature-sized pans, while others want something with more structure. I get it. That’s why I created this comprehensive list of the top seven – so you can find exactly what you’re looking for.
Let’s bake some muffins, shall we?
- Best Silicone Muffin Pan: Top Picks
- 1. CakeTime Silicone Muffin Pan (Top Choice)
- 2. Trudeau Structure Pro Silicone Muffin Pan (Most Structured Pan)
- 3. Cozihom Silicone Muffin Pan (Best Value)
- 4. CakeTime Silicone Muffin Pan Set (Best for Mini Muffins)
- 5. Walfos Silicone Texas Muffin Pan Set (Best for Jumbo Muffins)
- 6. Amazon Basics Reusable Silicone Baking Cups (Budget Pick)
- Best Silicone Muffin Pan: Things to Consider
Best Silicone Muffin Pan: Top Picks
There are plenty of great silicone muffin pans out there, but these ones stuck out thanks to their unique features, convenience, and great reviews.
1. CakeTime Silicone Muffin Pan (Top Choice)
- Key Features: Safe in temps -104F to 446F, dishwasher-safe, flexible for easy release, 1.1-inch depth
- Capacity: 12 muffins
- Size: 12.8 x 9.6 x 1.1 inches
- Weight: 7.7 ounces
Trust me; I love kitchen gadgets with all the bells and whistles. But sometimes, I just want simplicity and reliability. And that’s why I love this silicone muffin pan from CakeTime. It’s made entirely of food-grade, BPA-free silicone, offering a non-stick surface every time.
The pan itself comes with 12 muffin slots, the right size for most families. The cups offer a 1.1-inch depth, creating perfectly-sized muffins every time. When you’re done baking, pop them out with ease, thanks to the flexible construction. It’s never been easier!
Not sold just yet? Then you’ll be happy to hear that this pan handles temperatures ranging from -104F to 446F. Wow. It’s also dishwasher-safe, ensuring a swift clean-up every time. Who wants to spend hours scrubbing their “traditional” muffin pan? Not me!
When I say this muffin pan is flexible, I mean it’s really flexible. You might want to place a baking sheet underneath, especially when you’re setting the pan (full of wet and jiggly ingredients) into the oven to avoid spillage.
2. Trudeau Structure Pro Silicone Muffin Pan (Most Structured Pan)
- Key Features: 1.5-inch depth, dishwasher-safe, integrated with a steel frame for structure, silicone finish, handles temps up to 428F
- Capacity: 12 muffins
- Size: 1.5 x 10 x 14.4 inches
- Weight: 1.44 ounces
Although many other bakers and I love the flexible design, it’s not for everyone. Want more structure? Then you should consider the Trudeau muffin pan. This unique pan is integrated with a steel frame to keep it secured and structured while impressively lightweight.
On top of the steel frame, you’ll find the sought-after non-stick silicone finish. The entire pan is 100% dishwasher-safe for easy cleanup and provides an even, thorough bake every time. Did I mention the pan goes above and beyond FDA standards? Clearly, this is a pan you can trust.
This pan will provide you with slightly larger muffins, although it’s a 12-muffin pan. That’s because the depth is 1.5 inches rather than 1.1. It can withstand less heat than the #1 option, too, only allowing temperatures up to 428F.
Some reviewers claimed that it could leave some slight staining if the muffins get burned. You can avoid this by ensuring you’re not overcooking your muffins, not using temperatures above 428F, and cleaning after using them every time.
3. Cozihom Silicone Muffin Pan (Best Value)
- Key Features: Handles temps from -40F to 446F, dishwasher-safe, best value, durable yet flexible, 1.2-inch muffin depth, comes with three pans
- Capacity: 12 muffins
- Size: 11.5 x 8.7 x 1.2 inches
- Weight: 4.2 ounces
If you’re baking muffins like a madman (been there, done that), then one measly muffin pan isn’t going to cut it. If you’re looking to get multiple pans – and the biggest bang for your buck – you will love this three-pack of silicone muffin pans from Cozihome.
These three pans are designed with food-grade silicone and are entirely non-toxic, non-stick, and non-odor, giving you the confidence you crave while baking. They can handle temperatures ranging from -40F to 446F, making them a versatile solution in your kitchen.
Although these pans come with a notorious and convenient flexible design, they still offer an impressive amount of durability. With a depth of 1.2 inches, you can enjoy delicious and perfectly-shaped muffins for years.
Keep in mind that the more you fill them, the flimsier they will get. Some people may want to place these muffin pans on top of a baking sheet for added sturdiness when placed in the oven.
4. CakeTime Silicone Muffin Pan Set (Best for Mini Muffins)
- Key Features: Comes with a regular and mini muffin pan, handles temperatures -104F to 446F, versatile, ultra-flexible, bonus 12-pack of silicone liners
- Capacity: 12 or 24 muffins
- Size: 13.3 x 9.4 x 1.8 inches or 12.8 x 9.6 x 2.75 inches
- Weight: 8.2 ounces (for both)
CakeTime again? What can I say? When something works, don’t try to change it. CakeTime is a reliable brand, so I had to include their miniature muffin pan on this list. As a bonus, this set comes with a regular-sized pan, too, so you have options while baking.
These pans are designed with premium food-grade silicone. They’re designed to be ultra-flexible, infamous to the CakeTime brand. With an impressive 24 slots in the miniature pan, you can create adorable and delicious treats in no time.
Like my number one pick, these pans can handle temperatures from 104F to 446F. You simply won’t find that range of resistance with other brands. Oh, and one last thing – this set comes with 12 silicone cupcake liners, making your baking and clean-up more effortless than before.
Well, just like the other CakeTime product on this list, you’re going to need to use a baking sheet underneath these pans. They are so flexible it will be nearly impossible to place them inside the oven without some structure underneath.
5. Walfos Silicone Texas Muffin Pan Set (Best for Jumbo Muffins)
- Key Features: Jumbo pan, ultra-flexible, 3.5-inch muffins, BPA-free, handle temperatures from -104F to 446F, versatile, two-pack
- Capacity: Six muffins
- Size: 13.35 x 8.5 x 2.76 inches
- Weight: 1.09 pounds
I’ll be honest – I love how cute mini muffins are. But a jumbo muffin? Those make my jaw drop. There is just something so exciting about a muffin that’s almost as big as your head. Now, you can make effortless jumbo muffins in your own home with the Walfos pan.
This pan is designed with food-grade, BPA-free silicone and is ultra-flexible for easy release—no need to coat. Just fill the extra-large, 3.5-inch muffin slots with your favorite batter, bake, and pop out in a flash. So simple!
There’s plenty of versatility with this pan, too. It can handle temperatures from -104F to 446F and manage all applications such as the freezer, microwave, and dishwasher. Don’t want to wait? A quick swipe with hot soapy water and your pan will be good as new.
You will never guess what the biggest issue is with this pan. Yup, you guessed it – it’s super flexible. Just like most other silicone pans, you’re going to need something sturdy underneath it, so you don’t end up dropping batter every which way.
6. Amazon Basics Reusable Silicone Baking Cups (Budget Pick)
- Key Features: Pack of baking cups, dishwasher-safe, colorful cups, handle temps up to 428F, versatile
- Capacity: 12 or 24 muffins
- Size: 2.9 x 2.96 x 1.3 inches
- Weight: 4.5 ounces (all)
Okay, okay. I get it. This is not technically a silicone pan. But not everyone wants to spend money on a whole new pan. Or, they may simply not have the storage space to equip one. Sound like you? Then you will appreciate the addition of the Amazon Basics cups.
This pack of silicone baking cups (available in 12 and 24-cup options) is made from food-grade, BPA-free silicone. They’re great for adding to any muffin pan you currently own. Being dishwasher-safe, cleanup is a cinch for these handy cups.
These baking cups are ultra-versatile and can be used beyond baking. They’re safe in the freezer and microwave, opening up more possibilities in the kitchen. You will love how colorful these cups are, too, adding a sense of whimsy to your countertops.
Seeing as how these have a pleated design, there can sometimes be some leftover mess that needs to be hand-scrubbed. This isn’t the most convenient thing, but cleaning still isn’t too big of an issue compared to traditional muffin pans.
Best Silicone Muffin Pan: Things to Consider
Before you go out and start making muffins with your new pan, there are a few key things to consider first.
How big of a pan do you need? Most people are fine with the standard size. However, you might want to make some adorable miniature muffins or get some jumbo-sized delights in your home. Consider the size before making a final purchase.
Tip: Opt for a set that comes with both if you can’t decide!
While the bulk of the silicone muffin pans on this list can handle temperatures up to 446F, some can handle more or less. It’s essential to pay attention to the pan’s heat resistance before buying. Decide which temperature you use most often for muffins and buy accordingly.
It’s not just the size to concern yourself with. It’s the overall depth, too. Some of these pans are shallower than others, affecting the overall size. This is especially true for traditional-sized pans. Not all muffin pans are the same!
Do you want an ultra-flexible muffin pan to release your muffins quickly? Or do you crave more stability? While most silicone pans will have a lot of flexibility, some are designed to be more durable than others. Which one do you prefer?
Some of these pans have some stellar extras you might not want to miss. For example, the Baking & Beyond set contains spatulas and an ebook. The CakeTime set comes with two differently-sized pans. The Trudeau has an integrated steel frame for durability.
There are many muffin pans on this list, which might make it challenging to decide which one’s right for you. If you just can’t seem to make a decision, consider my number one pick: the CakeTime Silicone Muffin Pan. It’s a convenient and reliable pan for traditional-sized muffins.
Which muffin pan are you going to end up buying?About Michelle