5 Best Sifters for Baking

If you’re struggling with your measurements being a little off, you need a sifter. A sifter will ensure there are no clumps or other issues within the flour, sugar, etc., leaving you with perfect measurements – and perfect treats – every time. I recommend the YLYL 3 Pcs Super Wire Extra Fine Mesh Strainer with Handle.

Hey, there, folks! My name’s Michelle, and if I’m honest, I didn’t always sift my ingredients. In the beginning, I didn’t think it was “necessary.” Boy, was I wrong! Ten years later, I can confidently say that sifters are an absolute must when it comes to baking.

I like the YLYL strainers because they’re impossibly versatile and easy to use. The set comes with three different-sized strainers so you can easily tackle any job. They’re built tough with food-grade 304 stainless steel that’s long-lasting, won’t rust or bend, and is 100% dishwasher-safe.

Of course, I don’t expect everyone to love these sifters as I do. That’s why I have found five different highly rated sifters for baking to pique your interest. Whether you like old-school, hand-crank sifters or state-of-the-art electronic ones, you will find them below.

Find your next sifter below!

Best Sifter for Baking: Top Picks

Finding the ideal sifter doesn’t have to be a challenge. I’ve looked through countless sifters for baking to ensure I found the top five on the market. I checked out features, prices, and reviews to come up with my list. Let’s dive in, shall we?

1. YLYL 3 Pcs Super Wire Extra Fine Mesh Strainer with Handle (Best Choice)

• Key Features: Three different sizes, hanging ear, won’t rust or bend, dishwasher-safe, stainless steel, ergonomic handle, double-mesh

This three-pack from YLYL is a must-have for any kitchen. It comes in three different sizes, including 3.15, 5.5, and 7.87 inches. With so many size options, this versatile pack can handle all your sifting needs. They even work with wet and dry ingredients!

Another reason you’ll love this sifter? It’s built with high-quality, food-grade 304 stainless steel. Not only does this ensure your product won’t end up with rust or bent areas, but it’s also long-lasting – meaning you won’t have to worry about making another sifter purchase anytime soon.

These sifters are undeniably easy to use and 100% dishwasher safe, allowing for easy cleanup – which is imperative after a busy afternoon of baking. With a handy “hanging ear,” these sifters can be hung to dry and stored or stacked in your kitchen drawer with ease.

The only potential downside of these sifters is they don’t come with a clamp or anything to secure them to a bowl. While they should be able to balance on top of similarly-sized bowls, it isn’t secure – so be extra careful when sifting!

2. Norpro 3-Cup Rotary Hand Crank Flour Sifter (Best Rotary Hand Crank Option)

• Key Features: Hand-crank design, stainless steel construction, three-cup capacity, two-wire agitator, handy volume markings on the inside and outside

When some people think of a sifter for baking, they think of the old-school hand-crank sifters their grandmother used to use. And that’s okay. There’s a reason why grandma depended on them – they’re reliable and work like a charm.

If you’re hunting for a hand crank sifter, look no further than the Norpro. This hand crank sifter is easy to use and can handle up to three cups at a single time. Pretty impressive! Plus, there are volume markings on the inside and outside, making your job infinitely easier.

With the Norpro, there is no flour left behind. That’s thanks to the included two-wire agitator. Constructed with stainless steel, you can feel confident in a long-lasting tool that will see you through all of your cake-baking adventures.

While this hand crank flour sifter got plenty of excellent reviews, a few people said it didn’t sift “fine” enough. So, ingredients like powdered sugar (which is very fine) weren’t sifted all the way. Other than that, it’s a five-star product that everyone loves.

3. TriTree Battery Operated Electric Flour Sifter (Best Electric Option)

• Key Features: Battery-operated, easy to use, push-button control, four cup capacity, BPA-free, stainless steel mesh, easy to clean, sifts in seconds

In this day and age, most people are swapping their “traditional” items for more advanced, electronic ones. Well, if you’re someone that likes to stay with the times, you will appreciate this battery-operated sifter for baking.

The TriTree sifter is a serious game-changer when it comes to sifting. All you need to do is insert two double AA batteries, add your ingredients, and hold down the button, allowing the 5600 RPM to work its magic. No cranking and no squeezing of the handle is required.

The sifter has a reasonably impressive capacity, handling up to four cups of ingredients at a time. The body is made entirely of high-quality, BPA-free polycarbonates, while the mesh screen is constructed with stainless steel, offering ultimate confidence in your new tool.

The only downside to this electric sifter is that it’s somewhat challenging to clean, mainly because you can’t get the handle that houses the batteries wet. Other than that, people loved this sifter and claimed it was much easier to use than other gadgets.

4. HULISEN 3 Cup Flour Sifter and Biscuit Cutter (Best Value)

• Key Features: Four tools included, three-cup capacity, ergonomic rubber handles, safe to use, volume measurement markings on the exterior, stainless steel construction

I don’t know about you, but I love getting the biggest bang for my buck. That’s why I included this handy baking set from Hulisen. It comes with a sifter, biscuit butter, dough blender, and pastry cutter, which is excellent for those just starting in the baking world.

All the tools are designed with stainless steel, ensuring a long-lasting and rust-free product you can depend on. The sifter itself comes with a three-cup capacity, which is enough space – especially for newbies.

The tools also come with non-slip rubber grip handles. These handles offer superior comfort when it comes to cutting, blending, and scraping, but they also provide added stability for a safer workspace. Who doesn’t love to be safe while working?

This set is great, but the sifter can be a little hard to get used to. With a little trial and error, you can be successful with the sifter in no time, so I wouldn’t be overly concerned about it.

5. NPYPQ 5-Cup Stainless Steel Flour Sifter (Largest Capacity)

• Key Features: Five-cup capacity, stainless steel, mirror-polished aesthetics, easy to use, comfortable handle, double-mesh filter for precision

If you do a lot of baking, then three or four cups aren’t going to fulfill your needs. For extra-large capacity (up to five cups), you need the baking sifter from NPYPQ.

The NPYPQ baking sifter has an impressive five-cup capacity, ensuring all of your baking projects can be done in no time. It’s made entirely of resistant stainless steel, complete with a classy mirror-polished design that will look fab in your kitchen.

Don’t worry – this high-capacity sifter is a cinch to use. Just press the handle and let the sifter do the hard work for you. With a comfortable handle, you don’t have to fear hand strain, even if you’re sifting through huge batches of ingredients.

Last but not least, you will enjoy a double-mesh filter that can handle even the tiniest ingredients. The two-in-one system removes all clumps, so your baked goods come out perfect every time.

There weren’t any real negative reviews about this sifter for baking. The only “issue” is that some users thought it was on the flimsy side, but it did not affect how the product worked. And most people are still using theirs years later,

Best Sifter for Baking: Things to Consider

Knowing which sifters for baking are the best of the best is only half the battle. Now, you need to decide which one is right for you. Here are a few quick things to consider when shopping.

Type

The first thing to consider is the type of strainer you want. Do you want something more like a strainer, or do you prefer the old-school hand-cranked version? There are a few different options on this list, so first, decide which type is right for you.

Capacity

Next, consider the capacity. If you do a lot of baking, you will want to get at least a four-cup capacity, if not five. If you’re new to baking and don’t plan to use it as often, a lower capacity (three or fewer) will work just fine.

Extras

Each sifter comes with a unique feature in the “key features” section beneath the name. Sift through the features to find which ones you can’t live without. For example, you might prefer a battery-operated tool, while someone else wants double-mesh for added precision.

Price

Finally, consider the price! While none of these baking sifters are so high-priced they’ll break the bank, it’s still important to purchase a product that fits your budget comfortably. So, double-check the price of the sifter before making a final purchase.

The Verdict

With a new sifter under your belt, you’ll be sifting your way to top-notch treats in no time. I personally recommend the YLYL 3 Pcs Super Wire Extra Fine Mesh Strainer with Handle because I prefer the strainer type of sifter. Still, any of these sifters will be a wonderful addition to your baking projects.

What kind of sifter do you prefer? Which one of these sifters are you planning to buy? Do you have one to recommend? Share with us in the comments!

I have been a lover of sweets since day one. This led me on a self-taught baking journey starting at the age of 13. It's been over 10 years since the start of my baking adventures, and I’ve learned a lot along the way. Now, people rave about my delectable treats, whether it’s a chocolate cake or a strawberry crepe.