10 Best Non-Stick Muffin Pans

What’s for breakfast? Egg muffins. What’s for dessert? Ooey-gooey chocolate muffins. Are you catching my drift here? 

Muffins are super versatile and relatively easy to bake, making them a staple in almost every kitchen. Up your game with a premium non-stick muffin pan like the Wilton Perfect Results Premium.

Hi, there! My name is Michelle, and I’m a self-taught baker with over ten years of experience in the kitchen. Muffins are one of my favorite things to bake because there is a seemingly endless list of recipes, and they always turn out delicious. They’re one of my fave handheld treats!

Of course, this doesn’t mean I haven’t had a few muffin fiascos. The biggest issue arises when dealing with muffins that stick to the pan. Hello, half of my muffin. Not only does this ruin your muffins, but it makes the pan so incredibly challenging to clean.

The simple fix? Get a non-stick muffin pan that releases quickly, like the Wilton Non-Stick Muffin Pan. This top-tier pan is constructed of steel for durability and coated with non-stick and scratch-resistant material for perfect results every time. Did I mention it’s surprisingly budget-friendly, too?

If you’re on the hunt for a non-stick muffin pan you can trust, you’ve stumbled upon the right article. Below, you will find my must-see list of the top ten best muffin pans on the market, including jumbo and miniature sizes and all different kinds of materials.

Let’s bake some muffins!

Best Non-Stick Muffin Pan: Top Picks

There are a lot of muffin pan options out there, which makes it hard to choose the right one. Well, I’m here to make life easier for you. Below are the ten top choices. All you have to do is narrow it down to your number one pick!

1. Wilton Perfect Results Premium Non-Stick Muffin Pan (Top Choice)

• Key Features: Durable, long-lasting, non-stick, scratch-resistant, hand wash or dishwasher-safe
• Muffin Size: 12 
• Pan Size: 1.45 x 10.57 x 15.04 inches
• Material: Alloy steel
• Weight: 11.2 ounces

If you didn’t know already, Wilton is one of the absolute best brands on the market. They have been around since 1929 and have yet to disappoint. That said, it’s no wonder why their muffin pan made it to my number one spot.

Although this non-stick muffin pan is budget-friendly, it does not slack on features. This durable and reliable pan is crafted with steel to ensure sturdiness from start to finish. It’s coated with a non-stick and scratch-resistant coating, too, for easy release of all your favorite muffin flavors.

This 12-cup pan can be loaded into the dishwasher when you’re in a rush, although it is recommended to wash my hand with warm soapy water as often as possible to protect the non-stick coating. Needless to say, this is a convenient pan that will work in any kitchen.

There are thousands of positive reviews for this pan. In fact, the biggest downside had nothing to do with the actual pan but with shipping. Some pans arrived dented, but Wilton was more than willing to ship a replacement for these customers.

2. USA Pan Bakeware Muffin Pan (Runner-Up)

• Key Features: Designed with Americoat non-stick coating, fluted design, even heat distribution, advanced air circulation
• Muffin Size: 12 
• Pan Size: 15.75 x 1.3 x 1.33 inches
• Material: Aluminized Steel
• Weight: 1.9 Pounds

I’ll admit – it was hard to pick between the Wilton and the USA muffin pans. They’re both just such great non-stick pans! However, I put the USA in second place because it’s a bit pricier than Wilton, which might be a drawback for some shoppers.

The USA muffin pan is well worth the extra money, though. It comes with a nonstick Americoat coating that ensures a non-stick surface and quick release of muffins every time. It is also entirely PTFE, PFOA, and BPA-free, providing you confidence while you bake.

Another great feature is the fluted design. This unique texture increases overall air circulation, allowing for better heat distribution throughout the muffin pan. The result? Muffins that are baked evenly and taste oh-so-delicious.

It was hard to find any negative comments about this pan. Again, it came down to issues with shipping. A good amount of people received muffin pans that had scratches or dents. The good news is USA Bakeware replaced them swiftly and without hassle.

3. CakeTime Silicone Muffin Pan (Best Silicone Option)

• Key Features: Non-stick, ultra-flexible, easy release, dishwasher-safe
• Muffin Size: 12
• Pan Size: 12.8 x 9.6 x 1.1 inches
• Material: Silicone
• Weight: 7.7 ounces

When some people hear the term “non-stick,” their minds immediately go to silicone. If that’s you, you will want to add this CakeTime muffin pan to your kitchen arsenal. 

This 12-cup muffin pan is constructed using food-grade silicone, providing an entirely non-stick surface. It’s ultra-flexible to ensure you can literally “pop” your muffins out when they’re done. The non-stick and flexible combo also makes it a breeze to clean.

The added benefit of going the silicone route is you can wash it in the dishwasher without fear of damaging the pan. It can withstand temperatures of -104F to 446F, making it a versatile pan for all of your baked treats. 

This silicone pan is very flexible. I repeat this silicone pan is very flexible. Why am I shouting at you? Because you don’t want spills or mishaps along the way. I recommend using a baking sheet underneath this pan for much-needed stability. Other than that, it works like a charm!

4. Rachael Ray Yum -o Nonstick Bakeware Muffin Tin (Best Handles)

• Key Features: Extra-wide handles, grip handles, multiple color options available, sturdy, non-stick, warp-resistant, safe up to 500F
• Muffin Size: 12
• Pan Size: 15.5 x 10.5 x 1.5 inches
• Material: Alloy Steel
• Weight: 1.45 pounds

I don’t know about you, but I love a pan with good handles. That added sense of confidence and stability when you’re pulling your muffins out of the oven is essential. Well, that’s why I included the Rachael Ray Yum-o muffin pan in my top ten list.

Why will you love it? For one, these muffin pans are crafted using heavy-gauge steel for unparalleled sturdiness. It resists warping, while the non-stick coating allows for easy release and super simple cleanup with no residue left behind.

On each side, you will find grippy handles for a secure grasp unlike you’ve ever felt before. The grips are available in several color options, including orange and blue, so that you can add a pop of color to your kitchen in a flash. This pan is safe up to a surprising 500F, perfect for all your baking adventures. 

While this is undeniably a top-notch non-stick muffin pan, some shoppers said that the actual cup sizes were shallower and smaller than other pans they’ve used. It wasn’t a tremendous difference, but noticeable. I wouldn’t be super worried about it!

5. Wilton Perfect Results Non-Stick Mega Mini Muffin Pan (Ultimate Mini Muffin Pan)

• Key Features: Non-stick, scratch-resistant, maximizes oven space, sturdy and reliable
• Muffin Size: 48
• Pan Size: 0.93 x 21.5 x 15.5 inches
• Material: Alloy steel
• Weight: 2.92 Pounds

There are small muffins, and then there are seriously miniature-sized muffins. If you’re a fanatic about mini muffins like I am, you’re going to fall head over heels for this adorable and super convenient mini muffin pan from Wilton (yes, I had to mention another Wilton product!)

This mini non-stick muffin pan can accommodate up to a whopping 48 miniature muffins. Yes, you read that correctly. With so many cups, you can maximize your oven space while saving tons of time. Who doesn’t love that?

The pan is designed with sturdy steel and coated with a non-stick and scratch-resistant surface. Mini muffins pop out quickly, and you’ll love the simple cleanup, whether you place this pan in the dishwasher or scrub by hand.

With 48 slots, it’s pretty evident that this pan will be enormous and somewhat on the heavy side. While it is not too large to fit traditional ovens, getting this thing into the dishwasher might be a challenge. Not a big deal, though, since you can easily wash it by hand.

6. OvenStuff Non-Stick Jumbo Muffin Pan (Ultimate Jumbo Muffin Pan)

• Key Features: Makes wide and tall muffins, DuraGlide PLUS non-stick, quick food release, heavy-duty and durable
• Muffin Size: 6
• Pan Size: 8.5 x 1.75 x 12.75 inches
• Material: Alloy steel
• Weight: 12.6 Ounces

Ever in the mood for a muffin that is larger than life? Yeah, me too. There is nothing quite like a massive muffin, whether it’s sweet, savory, or somewhere in the middle. For all things jumbo muffins, use the OvenStuff muffin pan.

This high-quality pan is constructed using heavy-duty steel to ensure reliability and no hot spots, even years down the road. It’s coated with DuraGlide PLUS, a uniquely formulated coating that provides effortless muffin release and simple clean-up.

Overall, you can feel confident using this muffin pan for all of your jumbo-sized needs. With a 1.75-inch depth, your muffins will not only come out appealingly wide but surprisingly tall, too. This jumbo pan really emphasizes the word “jumbo!”

I would avoid the dishwasher with this one. Some buyers have said that the pan gets rusty, especially when in contact with water for too long. A quick wipe with a damp paper towel will be the best choice for cleanup. Scrub for stuck-on messes if necessary!

7. GreenLife Bakeware Healthy Ceramic Nonstick

• Key Features: Reinforced with steel, safe pan with no PFAS, PFOA, lead, or cadmium, non-stick, and easy to clean
• Muffin Size: 12
• Pan Size: 15 x 11 x 1 inches
• Material: Ceramic
• Weight: 1.65 pounds

I know plenty of people who are crazy about ceramics. If you’re one of them, then you’re going to want this premium non-stick muffin pan from GreenLike Bakeware. This company has made it its mission to create high-quality and safe baking products, and its muffin pan is so different.

This 12-cup ceramic muffin pan is designed with a non-stick coating that is entirely PFAS, PFOA, lead, and cadmium-free. This gives bakers the confidence they need to know they’re whipping up muffins that are going to not only taste great but be 100% safe to eat.

Although crafted using ceramic, this pan is reinforced with heavy-duty steel and reinforced rims to ensure it is strong enough to handle all of your baking projects. It also adds much-needed stability, reducing the risk of batter spills along the way.

These pans are unfortunately prone to chipping after several uses. It does not affect their efficiency, and you will not end up with any chips in your muffins, so don’t be overly concerned about that happening. It just won’t look as “pretty” over time.

8. Bruntmor Pre-seasoned Cast Iron Pan (Top Cast Iron Choice)

• Key Features: Pre-seasoned, even heat distribution, excellent heat retention, safe up to 500F, use with any application
• Muffin Size: 11
• Pan Size: 11.85 x 8.19 x 1.61 inches
• Material: Cast Iron
• Weight: 5.08 pounds

If your idea of a non-stick muffin pan is very hefty and reliable, you need a cast-iron pan. And that’s precisely what this Bruntmor Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Pan is all about.

This uniquely-designed muffin pan comes with 11 slots for the batter, which is something you won’t find with other muffin pans (it’s almost always 12 cups – how boring!). Made with cast iron, the pan offers superior heat retention and distribution for consistent baking every time.

The best part is this cast iron pan comes pre-seasoned, saving you plenty of time and hassle. Being pre-seasoned, you won’t have to worry about any muffin residue sticking to the pan, whether you’re baking in the oven, gas cooktop, or campfire. (Muffins at a campfire? Move over, S’Mores!)

People’s most prominent complaint about these pans was that some spots were a little rough, unlike the traditional smooth cast iron pans. They still functioned as necessary and produced delightful baked treats, but it wasn’t enjoyable to touch.

9. GPM Copper Muffin Pan (Best Copper Pan)

• Key Features: Copper-infused, extremely durable, PTFE and PFOA-free, nontoxic, dishwasher-safe
• Muffin Size: 12
• Pan Size: 13.7 x 11.02 x 2.6 inches
• Material: Copper
• Weight: 1.06 pounds

One of the best things about copper cookware is it is notoriously superior at evenly distributing heat – far better than competitor materials. No wonder why it’s so commonly found in a baker’s kitchen! For those on the market for a copper muffin pan, choose the GPM. Here’s why.

This copper-infused 12-cup muffin pan allows for exceptional heat distribution for muffins that come out perfect every time. It is coated with a non-stick material to enhance overall performance, allowing muffins to slide right out. 

With this nontoxic muffin pan, you can bake with ease, knowing that there are absolutely no PTFEs or PFOAs. The 100% food-grade copper is also highly durable and won’t release undesirable tastes or flavors into your baked goods. Perfection!

There were little to no complaints about this copper muffin pan. The only slight issue is that some people said the non-stick coating wasn’t as good a few uses down the line. I suggest spraying the pan before use and using the dishwasher as little as possible.

10. Chicago Metallic Muffin Top Pan (Best for Making Muffin Tops)

• Key Features: Creates muffin tops, heavy-duty, great heat conduction, even baking, dishwasher-safe
• Muffin Size: 6
• Pan Size: 15.75 x 11 x 0.5 inches
• Material: Alloy Steel
• Weight: 14.4 ounces

“Top of the morning… to you!” Are there any other Seinfeld fanatics out there? Then you would have recognized that line from the show any day. Apparently, Elaine was onto something. Now, you can bake your very own muffin tops right from home. Just use a non-stick pan like this one from Chicago Metallic.

This distinctive muffin top pan is constructed with heavy-duty carbon steel to last for years. It also offers excellent heat conduction for an overall even bake. Coated with a non-stick material, the surface allows muffin tops to slide right off in no time.

The best part? This 0.5-inch deep muffin pan is entirely dishwasher-safe. And no, you don’t have to worry about any undesirable effects like rusting or sticking after placing them in the dishwasher. 

This is a very shallow pan, so you need to be extra careful when placing it in the oven. Otherwise, you risk spilling your batter every which way. Who wants to worry about cleaning their kitchen when they’re trying to bake some delightful muffin treats?

Best Non-Stick Muffin Pan: Things to Consider

I know you’re dying to make a batch of muffins without worrying about sticky residues. But you need to consider a few essential things before making a final decision. Check it out!

Muffin Size

Are you a jumbo-sized kind of baker, or do you prefer tiny and adorable treats? Do you like to keep things “traditional”?” Think about the size of the muffins you’re planning to bake. The last thing you want to do is buy the wrong size.

Pan Size/Weight

The overall pan size and weight should also be considered. After all, you don’t want a pan that’s going to be too large to perform its purpose. Some people might not be keen on struggling with a hefty pan, either, so look over the stats before buying.

Material

Material is also a critical element to consider when finding the muffin pan that’s right for you. Really, it comes down to personal preference. Most people will be fine with steel options, but others want the flexibility of silicone, even the heat distribution of copper, or the sturdiness of cast iron.

Added Features

The great thing about these pans is that they are all different. They will all yield non-stick results, but some have other “extras” such as dishwasher-safe, constructed with grippy handles, or scratch-resistant. Which features are essential for you?

Verdict

Now, you can finally create the muffins of your dreams – without the mess or hassle. The Wilton Perfect Results Premium Non-Stick Muffin Pan is my favorite because it’s reliable, durable, and convenient; however, any of these top-notch pans are sure to “wow.” 

Happy baking!

About Michelle