Baking cookies is all fun and games until it’s time to store them. What’s the use of delicious, freshly baked cookies if you can’t store them properly? To reduce the risk of dried-out treats, use a suitable cookie storage container like the OXO Good Grips POP Container.
Hi, there, bakers! My name is Michelle, and I’ve been baking cookies for years. They’re one of my absolute favorite things to bake, regardless of the flavor. You honestly can’t go wrong with cookies, whether it’s for a birthday party, a bake sale, or just because!
However, I can tell you one thing – you need a good storage container on your side. I have dealt with many mishaps during my baking journey. And biting into a cookie that was once soft and chewy – but has become a dried-out and crunchy mess – is nothing short of disappointing.
I use the OXO container to ensure my cookies are always in premium condition, even days after storage. The OXO container has plenty of room yet is a sleek and modern solid plastic container. The push-top lid ensures an airtight seal, keeping cookies safe from the elements.
Now, you might not be a fan of the OXO container. Maybe you prefer a classic cookie jar or something made of glass. No worries. I have made a must-see list of the seven best cookie storage containers in 2022, so you can find exactly what you’re looking for.
Who’s ready to discuss cookie storage?
- Best Cookie Storage Container: Top Picks 2022
- 1. OXO Good Grips POP Container (Top Choice)
- 2. Rubbermaid Leak-Proof Brilliance Food Storage Set (Best for Frosted Cookies)
- 3. LocknLock Easy Essentials Food Lids (Budget Pick)
- 4. Anchor Hocking Heritage Hill Jar (Glass Option)
- 5. DII Kitchen Accessories Collection Ceramics Cookie Jar (Ceramic Pick)
- 6. Sweetzer & Orange Airtight Glass Jar with Bamboo Lid (Smallest Jar)
- 7. Pacific Giftware Retro Oven Freshly Baked Ceramic Cookie Jar (Most Unique)
- Best Cookie Storage Container: Things to Consider
Best Cookie Storage Container: Top Picks 2022
A good storage container will change your cookie life – for good. While all of these containers are great choices, pay close attention to the key features to find the one that’s right for you.
1. OXO Good Grips POP Container (Top Choice)
- Key Features: Easy cleanup, BPA-free and strong plastic, dishwasher-safe, button lid for security and added freshness, easy to use, stackable, large capacity
- Size: 2.8 quarts
- Material: Plastic
When you need a reliable cookie storage container that can handle projects big and small, look no further than the OXO Good Grips POP Container. These containers are built for convenience and durability, so you won’t need to buy another container anytime soon.
What’s to love about these containers? For one, they’re space-efficient and can be stacked with other POP containers if necessary. This means you won’t have to worry about losing essential space in your kitchen, which isn’t true for all kinds of cookie jars.
Simplicity is vital with these solid plastic jars. They can hold up to 2.8 quarts of cookie goodness, and they are entirely dishwasher-safe. This makes cleanup a breeze while also deterring any odors from building up.
The best feature is the lid. There is a convenient button in the middle that locks in freshness. Push it up when you’re ready to load your cookie or want to grab a bite. Push the button down when you’re prepared to create a genuinely airtight seal that works like magic.
Some shoppers weren’t thrilled with the price. But honestly, you get what you pay for. These are undeniably the handiest and most durable containers on this list. I believe they are well worth the price.
2. Rubbermaid Leak-Proof Brilliance Food Storage Set (Best for Frosted Cookies)
- Key Features: Pack of two, the biggest bang for your dollar, BPA-free and durable plastic, 360 views, perfect for frosted cookies, easily stackable, dishwasher-safe
- Size: 1.3, 3.2, 4.7, or 9.6 Cup
- Material: Plastic
Have you ever tried to store frosted cookies in a “normal” cookie jar? Forget about it. That’s the quickest way to destroy all of your hard work. Obviously, we want to avoid this at all costs. To do that, you need a flat storage container to accommodate your decorated cookies.
That’s where the Rubbermaid set comes into play. This set comes with two 100% airtight containers constructed short and wide, creating the perfect setup for storing cookies in a single layer. They’re made with BPA-free, ultra-strong plastic to ensure their safety and durability, too.
These uniquely designed cookie storage containers also come with handy vents underneath the latches to allow for airflow when necessary. They can also be tossed in the freezer, cabinet, or dishwasher without getting ruined. Conveniently stack two or more containers to save space!
Last but not least, I love that these containers are entirely see-through. I’m the type of person who needs to know how many cookies I have left to whip up another batch. With a complete 360 view of my cookies, I know exactly when to start stirring ingredients.
These storage containers tend to retain strong smells, so I wouldn’t suggest using them for anything other than cookies or cookie-related ingredients like sugar, walnuts, candies, etc.
3. LocknLock Easy Essentials Food Lids (Budget Pick)
- Key Features: BPA-free, safe and eco-friendly, easy access flip-top lid, strong and durable, dishwasher-safe
- Size: 10.6, 21, or 50.7 cups
- Material: Plastic
Looking for a great deal when it comes to cookie storage? This is the best choice whether you’re a classic chocolate chip kind of baker or prefer wilder flavors like zesty lemon.
The LockNLock cookie storage container is made with BPA-free plastic that’s safe and eco-friendly; that’s a win-win we can all get behind. It’s super high-quality, too, which means it will last for an impressive amount of time and is durable enough to withstand almost anything.
My favorite part about this cookie storage is that it comes with a unique easy access flip lid. Just pop open the lid, grab up the cookies, and scarf them down as you walk back to your bedroom. It’s safe in the freezer and microwave (if necessary) but is also dishwasher-safe.
After all, the last thing you want is for flavors to combine – especially if they’re two very distinct and different flavors. Simply pop this storage into the dishwasher and prepare it for a new batch of delectable baked treats.
These storage containers could be a tad more airtight. But hey – you’re paying less than $10 for this top-notch cookie storage container. Can we really complain about something so simple? I’d say it’s well worth it, especially for the price and convenience.
4. Anchor Hocking Heritage Hill Jar (Glass Option)
- Key Features: Elegant appearance, airtight seal, robust jar with accompanying lid, spacious, see-through for convenience
- Size: ½, 1, or 2 gallons
- Material: Glass
When some people think of a cookie storage container, they think of a sophisticated and fancy glass jar – you know, like the one Grandma used to have in her kitchen. If you’re a devotee to glass cookie containers, then you will undoubtedly love this model from Anchor Hocking.
These glass jars come in extra-large sizes to accommodate even the busiest baker. Opt for the ½ gallon for smaller projects or the two-gallon product if you’re planning on making tons and tons of holiday cookie treats.
Regardless of the size, you know you’re buying a glass cookie jar that is elegant enough to be placed on any kitchen countertop. It’s a robust glass with an equally strong lid that provides an airtight seal for keeping cookies fresh – which is essential, especially for significant cookie undertakings.
Perhaps the best part about this hefty glass cookie container is that you can clearly see what’s going on inside. No more disappointment when you unknowingly grab up the last cookie in the cookie jar!
These decorative glass jars are great for storing your beloved cookies. But keep in mind, it’s deafening. It’s made entirely of glass, so placing the lid on top of the jar sounds like something is crashing and going haywire in your kitchen. My suggestion? Slow and steady wins the race.
5. DII Kitchen Accessories Collection Ceramics Cookie Jar (Ceramic Pick)
- Key Features: Charming and vintage, airtight seal with silicone gasket, many color options
- Size: 10.5 cups
- Material: Ceramic
Love ceramic? How about a cookie jar that’s oh-so-simple yet with an adorable vintage twist? The DII cookie jar is exactly what you need if you’re a ceramic and vintage-loving baker.
This cute cookie jar comes with the phrase “Fresh Homemade Cookies” across the front. Available in various colors, including aqua, red, blue, dark green, and black, it’s easy for everyone to find a jar that matches their kitchen’s personality and style.
Aside from the charming exterior, you will love that this cookie jar holds 10.5 cups worth of cookies and comes with a silicone gasket to create an airtight seal immediately. Finally, you can keep your cookies safe from pests like ants or dryness in the air.
Shoppers loved this endearing cookie jar, but one issue was that it was a bit smaller than they were hoping. It’s best to double-check the capacity and dimension of a cookie storage container before buying so you’re not caught off guard.
6. Sweetzer & Orange Airtight Glass Jar with Bamboo Lid (Smallest Jar)
- Key Features: Sleek yet rustic, perfect for mini cookies, bamboo lid, airtight seal, 3mm thickness
- Size: 785ml, 1.175 L, 1.57 L, 2.2 L
- Material: Glass
Sometimes I love making mini cookies. They’re the perfect bite-sized goodies, especially for a kid’s lunchbox or small container on the go. But these tiny treats can get lost in traditional-sized cookie storage containers, which is less than ideal.
If you’re anything like me and make miniature-sized cookies regularly, consider adding the Sweetzer & Orange jar to your kitchen arsenal. These jars are minimalist and designed for bite-sized goodies, looking fab on any kitchen countertop regardless of kitchen style.
One of my favorite things about these containers is the bamboo lid atop the 3mm-thick glass jar. The bamboo lid adds a natural touch to this jar, making it the ideal combination of sleek, modern, and rustic.
Now, these jars are truly airtight, and that’s proven by the inevitable “pop” noise that comes from removing the lid. While other jars might be thinner, leaner, and not as airtight, these jars provide utmost confidence for the user. You will love these thick, hefty, and glamorous jars.
There were next to no negative reviews for these cookie storage containers. They’re reliable, thick, and utterly sleek. The only issue is with packaging. Some people thought that the jars should’ve been cradled better, considering they’re made of glass.
7. Pacific Giftware Retro Oven Freshly Baked Ceramic Cookie Jar (Most Unique)
- Key Features: Charming retro design, funky and unique decor, handpainted
- Material: Ceramic
I don’t know about you, but I love out-of-the-box and slightly kitschy decor, especially in my kitchen. That’s why I added this unique cookie jar from Pacific Giftware.
This charming jar sweeps you back to the 1950s when pink appliances and decor were a staple in almost every kitchen. The adorable jar comes with a lovely pink-hued appliance. To get the cookies, simply lift off the “stovetop” and grab as many cookies as you want (we won’t tell!).
One cool feature about these cookie jars is they are 100% hand painted. If you’re interested in items that really took time, effort, and precision, then you will thoroughly enjoy having this retro cookie storage container sitting on your kitchen island. It makes a great housewarming gift!
This is another cookie jar that was surprisingly smaller than expected. I can’t stress this enough: pay attention to the dimensions and capacity! This will help you understand how big the storage container is and how many cookies will fit inside.
Best Cookie Storage Container: Things to Consider
I’m sure you’re excited to put an end to the dried-out, old, and stale cookie debacle. But before purchasing one of these top-notch containers, consider these few things.
Some people were surprised at how small some of these cookie storage containers were, while others were shockingly big. The best thing to do is look at the dimensions of each storage container and find one that suits your needs.
This goes hand in hand with size. Pay attention to how much capacity the storage container has. Otherwise, you might make a fresh batch of cookies, only to realize that you do not have enough storage space to accommodate them all.
Are you a fan of glass containers? Or do you prefer plastic? There are a few different kinds of materials on this list, and each has its pros and cons. For example, glass is glamorous, but plastic is easier to clean. Find the material that’s right for you.
Personally, I love to have a decorative cookie jar on my countertop. But I am also a fan of a modern and straightforward plastic container. Which one do you prefer? You can always get both if you can’t decide (like me). The more storage, the better, right?
You want a cookie storage container to ensure your cookies don’t dry up or become riddled with ants and other pesky bugs. Well, the best way to do that is with an airtight seal. While these cookie jars will keep predators and dryness at bay, some are better situated for airtight capacity than others.
These cookie storage containers are serious game changers, but my favorite is the OXO Good Grips POP Container. It’s a reliable and convenient container everyone can benefit from. Plus, the push top gives you full control over the airtight seal, which is a plus you won’t find elsewhere.About Michelle